GM Free Cymru

The Case of IntactaTM Roundup ReadyTM 2 Pro Soybean Farming in Brazil in light of the Norwegian Gene Technology Act

Date Added to website 20 June 2015


---------------------
The Case of IntactaTM Roundup ReadyTM 2 Pro Soybean Farming in Brazil in light of the Norwegian Gene Technology Act
-------------------------

[Comment: this is a careful study written in the context of the ongoing assessment of GMOs in the light of the rather interesting Gene Technology Act in Norway. All GMOs that might be used or planted in the country have to pass three tests -- there have to be sustainable development gains, societal benefits and ethical justifiability. The rest of Europe has a lot to learn......]

Author: Georgina Catacora-Vargas, GenØk – Centre for Biosafety

Biosafety report: Sustainability Assessment of Genetically Modified Herbicide Tolerant Crops
02.06.2015
Biosafety report 2014/02
010615_GENOK-HTIntactaBrazil-FINAL_web.pdf


Report abstract

This report seeks to contribute to the operationalization of the concepts of “sustainable development”, “societal benefits” and “ethical justifiability” of the Norwegian Gene Technology Act. In order to achieve this, the report addresses the questions surrounding the sustainability of herbicide-tolerant crops identified by the Norwegian Biotechnology Advisory Board. The report uses the case of IntactaTM Roundup ReadyTM 2Pro—a genetically modified stacked crop–used in Brazilian agriculture. This report summarizes, consolidates and contrasts the information provided by the dossier on the environmental and food biosafety of IntactaTM Roundup ReadyTM 2Pro submitted by the applicant to the Brazilian authorities, as well as different findings reported by relevant empirical studies. The compiled information is organized in two sections. The first part addresses ecological aspects of the genetically modified herbicide tolerant plant and its related herbicide (glyphosate and related commercial formulations). The second section describes social and economic issues. Of particular importance, the report contrasts the applicant´s conclusions regarding the absence of adverse effects against the literature’s findings on the existence of an array of possible harmful impacts. Given the current emphasis on types of production systems, the set of indicators used, and the focus on specific characteristics of herbicide tolerant crops, it can be recognized that the current state of knowledge on the sustainability of herbicide tolerant crops is incomplete.


Reference:
Catacora-Vargas G. (2014). Sustainability Assessment of Genetically Modified Herbicide Tolerant Crops. The Case of IntactaTM Roundup ReadyTM 2 Pro Soybean Farming in Brazil in light of the Norwegian Gene Technology Act. Biosafety Report 2014/02. Tromsø, GenØk–Centre for Biosafety.

- See more at: http://genok.com/arkiv/4185/#sthash.ZlPv5Oxw.dpuf